Pros and Cons of Extracting Metal Versus Recycling Scrap Metal

Updated On
Extracting Metal Versus Recycling

We may collect a share of sales from items linked to on this page. Learn more.

Metal is extracted from the soil. It is then refined, processed, and transported to various manufacturers, where it will undergo further procedures to become products.

However, these processes do a lot of damage to the environment.

To offset the damages, we are encouraged to recycle metal.

Below are the pros and cons of extracting raw metal versus recycling scrap metal.

Extracting Raw Metal

Advantages: Raw metal can be a source of valuable revenue.

It can be exported and sold to countries that consume metal the most, such as China and the United States.

Extracting raw metal also creates jobs for a lot of people, and so does the processing, refining, and transporting of the metal.

This will also prompt an increase in facilities such as hospitals, transport systems, and other facilities near mines.

Companies that deal in metal have to pay taxes, and the money coming from the taxes can help improve the economy of not only the local community but the government as well.

Disadvantages: Extracting metal harms the environment. Not only does it cause soil, water, and air pollution, but it also causes noise pollution.

If the company doesn’t do anything to alleviate pollution, the community will suffer the consequences.

Extracting metal also helps deplete natural resources.

After all, the process of turning raw metal into end products requires the use of other natural resources such as other metals, fuel, oil, wood, etc.

Recycling Scrap Metal

Advantages: The biggest advantage of recycling metal is that it is very earth-friendly.

There’s no more need to extract metal since the materials are readily available in the form of scrap metal.

Furthermore, since scrap metal has already been refined and processed, it’ll need fewer resources to recycle them and turn them into the desired end product, such as metal garages and sheds, as well as metal carports and barns.

Aside from this, using recycled metal also reduces waste and garbage accumulation in landfills, which is one of the biggest problems right now.

By recycling metal, the risk of polluting the land, soil, and water is greatly reduced.

Finally, recycling metal is less expensive and more economical compared to extracting raw metal. It also needs less energy, helping us save precious fuel.

Disadvantages: It cannot be denied that recycling metal creates fewer jobs compared to extracting the natural resource; however, the advantages of this still far outweigh the disadvantages.

The Need for Metal

We will always have the need for metal. We need them for so many reasons.

Metal is used in the construction company in constructing buildings; in the automotive industry for manufacturing vehicles; in the appliance and electronics industry for our refrigerators, TVs, mobile phones, and gadgets; in the food and beverage industry in the production of aluminum cans and containers, stainless steel countertops, cabinets, shelves; and in the rail and railroad industry for the construction of roads as well as rail roads, bridges, and tunnels.

We need metal and will always need this natural resource as our population grows.

To help our planet, we have to patronize companies that make use of recycled metal.

  • Guest Author

    Greener Ideal strives to help you live your life in more sustainable ways with green living tips, healthy recipes and commentary on the latest environment news. The views expressed by guest authors are their own and may not reflect those of Greener Ideal.

5 thoughts on “Pros and Cons of Extracting Metal Versus Recycling Scrap Metal”

  1. In general terms this article is good but lacks detail in any form for instance the various qualities of steel stainless etc and when the economy is weak the parameters

  2. “Their metal structures are made from recycled metal, and by choosing a metal garage over a wooden one, you get to help the environment in your own little way.” On this statement we can argue, cause in many cases it could be the opposite of saving environment.

  3. How interesting that you mention that recycling scrap metal is very earth-friendly. I am thinking of starting a new business this summer where we would want to start recycling scrap metal. I will find a reputable scrap metal recycling service in my area.


What do you think? Leave a comment!