Carbon Offsetting Not All It’s Cracked Up To Be?

Updated On

We may collect a share of sales from items linked to on this page. Learn more.

Here’s an interesting little debate that’s going on behind the scenes of the environmental movement: whether or not the preservation of rainforests may be a futile approach to keeping our air clean. Robin Oakley, a climate and energy campaigner for Greenpeace, says that carbon offsetting only makes people feel better about themselves and regardless of whether they are preserving rainforest space to “lock-in” a certain amount of carbon, the damage that has already been done by fossil-fuels cannot be stabilized in this way.

In fact, Oakley says, most carbon offsetting companies are not NPOs and are actually making “a killing” from people who purchase carbon credits. Charlie Kronick, the senior climate advisor to Greenpeace, thinks that this process is only turning the rainforest into a commodity, and “is not going to protect the climate or the lives of the people who live there”.

Along with purchasing leasing sections of the rainforest, other initiatives being taken by organizations is the planting of trees that are supposed to counteract the harmful effects that fossil fuel consumption has caused. And even though there are many high-profile names in support of this method (Al Gore, Sting, Sienna Miller, Tony Blair, Josh Hartnett, Desmond Tutu and Prince Charles just to name a few), it all comes back to making little difference, except in their own perception.Greenpeace is urging people to pay less to buying up a “tonne of cool”, and instead look at more environmentally friendly ways to travel.

As Ted Turner has said, “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” and no matter how much rainforest we preserve, it won’t make a difference if the rest of the world is full of pollution.

  • Ian Andrew

    As the Co-founder and Editor-in-Chief of Greener Ideal, Ian has been a driving force in environmental journalism and sustainable lifestyle advocacy since 2008. With over a decade of dedicated involvement in environmental matters, Ian has established himself as a respected expert in the field. Under his leadership, Greener Ideal has consistently delivered independent news and insightful content that empowers readers to engage with and understand pressing environmental issues.

    Ian’s expertise extends beyond editorial leadership; his hands-on experience in exploring and implementing sustainable practices equips him with practical knowledge that resonates with both industry professionals and eco-conscious audiences. This blend of direct involvement and editorial oversight has positioned Ian as a credible and authoritative voice in environmental journalism and sustainable living.

What do you think? Leave a comment!